|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/31/2004 12:32:31 PM
Good detail, good color, good depth of field, good title. Sounds like a great field study. Nice work.
|
Photo By: Bradley Prue
(K:30678)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/31/2004 12:28:06 PM
Nice macro. I like the contrast of the yellow pollen on the purple pedals.
|
| Photo By: Katarzyna Sroka
(K:27)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/31/2004 12:19:40 PM
Wow. I never even noticed the plane. You're right it does balance it out. The clouds presence is so strong the other elements are barely noticeable. Good work. --Todd
|
| Photo By: John H.
(K:2158)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/31/2004 3:40:31 AM
Great image! Love the infrared filter on this one. I'll have to get one for my Nikon. Train tracks are a classic, but you've twisted it into an original. Excellent clouds. You chose a good moment. Regards. --Todd
|
| Photo By: Rick Page
(K:5242)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/31/2004 3:36:52 AM
Great sky shot. Love the backlit clouds. The power lines could be slightly distracting to some from the "clean" sky image, but I barely noticed myself. Nice color.
|
| Photo By: John H.
(K:2158)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/30/2004 4:22:50 AM
Nice catch. I think it would work well cropped as well.
|
| Photo By: taitaifei
(K:0)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/30/2004 4:20:20 AM
Brilliant colors and good detail.
|
| Photo By: Roberta Elena Dragan
(K:345)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/30/2004 4:18:05 AM
Nice b/w. Interesting negative effect in the sky.
|
| Photo By: Paul Sanders
(K:744)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/30/2004 4:17:19 AM
Looks like it was worth the hike. Beautiful view.
|
| Photo By: Joe Suchman
(K:50)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/30/2004 3:28:00 AM
nice catch.
|
| Photo By: John Strazza
(K:11535)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/29/2004 4:16:02 AM
Nice work. I thought about infrared. Seems difficult. maybe one day...
|
| Photo By: Brad
(K:179)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/28/2004 2:05:50 AM
Great editorial Rafi. regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: Dr. Rafael Springmann
(K:89517)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
8/28/2004 1:05:13 AM
Nice photo. I love the ominous feeling and contrast of the clouds and sun and the positions of the cows exactly 90 degrees from each other. Good color. Surreal.
|
| Photo By: cyano
(K:6)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
6/10/2004 9:10:31 PM
Interesting reflective work Rafael. I enjoyed it.
|
| Photo By: Dr. Rafael Springmann
(K:89517)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
11/12/2003 6:15:42 AM
This is a very good composition, however, I agree that the image needs some work. It is quite overcast with grey which is typical of digital scans or photos sometimes. I am also a fan of levels but I also finish off using curves to tweek the image just the way I like it. I think Jim's rendition has removed the "cloud" and corrected the color. I personally would brighten up the colors a bit but I think it's important not to over do it. Eric's rendition in my opinion has stepped over the reality line as he admits himself. I think the green got layed on a little heavy in this one. Somewhere in the middle is where I like to be. Since everyone else had their hand at this, I couldn't resist adding my personal touch. That way you'll have 4 variations of the same photo to choose from. Color is subjective to the viewer, however, the "cloud" should be removed regardless and can be done quite easily by bringing your triangles to the edge of the histogram in levels. Just make sure your numbers all match in R, G, and B modes, otherwise your color correction will be off. This is probably the longest critique I've written in a while, but I love tigers, so...
|
| Photo By: Bob Atkinson
(K:393)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/31/2003 7:51:46 PM
Very cool. Nice abstract. regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: Adelino Barreto
(K:12661)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/31/2003 2:28:52 PM
Beautiful monochromatic photo. The birds silhuette breaks up the upper photo just enough. regards--Todd
|
| Photo By: Hayri CALISKAN
(K:16195)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/31/2003 2:25:29 PM
Beautiful photograph. However, the fisheye lens turns the mountain a little too much in my opinion. Is that nitpicking? Anyways, the exzposure and composition are great. No blowout in the sky and good detail throughout. regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: John Bohner
(K:8368)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/31/2003 2:12:14 PM
Really beautiful photo. The colors and reflection with the rainbow really make for an incredible comp. Great job. regards--Todd
|
| Photo By: Edeltraud Vinckx
(K:5559)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/17/2003 10:49:19 AM
Beautiful shot. The colors are magnificent. I'm sure you're glad you bracketed so many shots. Regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: Laurie J. Herndon
(K:5338)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/14/2003 9:20:30 PM
Wow. What a beautiful place! Maybe some shadows could be dodged but a really nice composition and beautiful clouds. Thanks for sharing. --Todd
|
| Photo By: Ana Vianna
(K:15270)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/14/2003 8:59:39 PM
Beautiful b/w work. A penthouse of outhouses. I like the humorous title too. Great detail in the outhouse. I don't understand the loss of detail in the grass to the left though, unless its the scan. In answer to your question: It is some sort of moss that grows on stones. You'll find quite a bit of it if your ever hiking 1700 ft up one of the Blue Ridge Mountains in Virginia. That's where I found this fine speciman. regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: Brian Hynes
(K:522)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/14/2003 8:48:07 PM
I see the faces. Nice PS work but I personally think it works on its own as an architectural photo. The building has a lot of character on its own. regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: Jason Hanson
(K:490)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/14/2003 8:19:12 PM
Beautiful speciman and excellent composition. The focus is soft but hard to master in a macro from my experience. nice piece. regards. --Todd
|
| Photo By: Cesar Pinedo
(K:1151)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/11/2003 1:43:30 PM
What a message! I love the feeling in it, the one that dared to be different. Nice catch. regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: Bulent Ahiskal
(K:1251)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/11/2003 1:24:58 PM
I like the idea but the branches up top are a little distracting. I like the composition but I think the darks are a little too dark. It looks like this would be hard to catch all the variation of lighting given the time of day. A little dodging and burning might help this shot but then you might lose some of the contrast which actually helps the composition. a conundrum. regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: HEERAK NANDY
(K:694)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
10/11/2003 12:51:18 PM
Very artistic. I like the mood and the colors. I also like the focus on the girl while the musician seems oblivious, lost in his music making. The texture of the ground is great and the seclusion adds to the mood. Nice work. regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: emrah soylemez
(K:577)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
9/16/2003 12:33:03 PM
This is absolutely beautiful. Stunning really! The petals look like a hand holding a microcosm on the end of its thumb. Really really really great. So glad you decided to share it. Best regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: Ursula I Abresch
(K:6515)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
9/4/2003 6:20:40 AM
Very provocative. Dramatic lighting and pose work to convey the meaning of the photo. The tussled hair over the face gives a careless/hopeless feeling along with the loose grip on her (her lovers?) shirt. Good work. Regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: frans jacobs
(K:42)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Todd Broadbent (K:2204)
9/4/2003 6:13:07 AM
Great lighting, color and composition. Just starting to lose detail on the bottom left, but could be my monitor. Tells a good story. Regards --Todd
|
| Photo By: Cathy Barrows
(K:1897)
|
|
