|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
6/13/2008 4:00:36 PM
Bardzo piekne zdjecie,
nie wiem dlaczego ale od razu pewien bylem, ze to zdejcie bylo z Polski. Polscy autorzy maja ciagle to nostalgiczne podejscie, ale bardzo lubie...glebia ostrosci swietnie pokazuje modelke...
Gratuluje i pozdrawiam serdecznie
|
| Photo By: Bartosz Sobanek
(K:106)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
6/13/2008 3:51:24 PM
Hello,
very beautiful sunset but in my humble opinion you have two problems of composition : the horizon is just in the middle of the picture and there is a lack of subject (a bird or a boat) placed in a strong point...
Regards
|
| Photo By: Larry Fosse
(K:66493)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
11/19/2007 10:44:37 AM
Alors comme ça on s'en vas aux Netherlands!!!!
C'est ça qui est bon!!!!
Quant à cette photo elle est vraiment réussie...évidemment j'adore le reflet sur la vitre. Juste le coin en haut à gauche est cramé et doit être foncé pour bien renfermer l'image. Encore bien vu mec!!!!
A bientôt.
Andrea
|
| Photo By: Frank Desfours
(K:257)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
10/25/2007 2:27:14 PM
Yo Franki,
félicitations pour le prix mec...ton idée est chanmé et elle mérite largement la récompense!!!
Maintenant, du point de vue de l'othodoxie j'ai quelques observations à faire: 1) tu as gardé la photo en couleurs, alors qu'il n'y a pas de couleurs...dans ce cas tu devrais retourner au même endroit et attendre qu'il y ait un vélo qui passe avec quelqu'un portant de jolis vêtements avec des couleurs flashy...tu risques d'attendre longtemps, mais c'est le prix à payer 2) essaye de refaire la photo avec une plus longue focale (car je sais o combien tu l'as recadrée), outre être un excellent exo de cadrage tu gagneras en piqué...
Voilà mec, et encore bravo!!! Je kiffe grave ce genre d'image bien bien graphiques!!!!
A plus mec!!!
|
| Photo By: Frank Desfours
(K:257)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
4/6/2007 3:45:27 PM
This is B&W!!!
Is the scan the same as in your last picture?
Regards!!!
|
| Photo By: Waleed AL-MARHOUM
(K:223)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
4/6/2007 3:43:40 PM
Hello Waleed,
I agree that the subject and the composition of your photography are great! But I regret that we can see only a few greys...in my humble opinion, it seems to me that this black and white is too plat! Maybe the scan?
regards
|
| Photo By: Waleed AL-MARHOUM
(K:223)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
4/4/2007 3:19:11 PM
Hi Franki!!!
prix mérité mec...j'espère que ça va bien t'encourager pour la suite!!! T'as bien choisi le projet...cette photo m'intrigue pas mal, comme quoi faut pas toujours avoir un personnage. Cependant les masses sont bien équilibrées et en plus ferment bien l'image. Un bon cliché que tu nous ramènes là de New York!
Salut Franki!!!
|
| Photo By: Frank Desfours
(K:257)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
11/18/2006 9:30:48 PM
Hello my friend,
I also have this camera!!! Very beautiful, did you take this picture with the retro mounted position of the lens?
Your picture has beautiful colors and is well composed, I just regret the completly white corne up on the right...a detail.
Regards!!!
Andrea
|
| Photo By: Ahmad Hasan
(K:4164)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
11/18/2006 9:06:34 PM
Hello Olga,
beautiful portrait in an olsfashioned decor, it gives a special atmosphere, melanconic...also beautiful light!! The composition is well studied!!
Regards
|
| Photo By: Olga Marken
(K:11)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
11/18/2006 8:47:57 PM
Czesc,
dobra kompozicja...lubie to zlote swiatlo i mgla razem...wedlug mnie jest udanym zdjeciem.
Pozdrowienia
Andrea
|
| Photo By: Ivonne *
(K:8711)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
10/17/2006 9:16:13 PM
Ca aussi c'est bon Frank!!!
Les contre-jours et les silhouettes ça te fait bien kiffer, moi aussi...mais comme tu sais ça donne des photos difficiles à tirer ou à traiter, selon la technique. Par exemple ici tout le coin en haut à gauche est bien trop clair. Le ciel demande d'etre obscurci!!! De plus qu'il y a de la matière, on devine quelques jolis nuages...en les renforçant tu augmenterais l'effet dramatique de la scène. Il faut absolument que tu essaies.
La composition est parfaite, rien à dire, et tu as su capturer le magique "instant décisif", dans ce cas l'instant meme ou le pecheur jette son filet.
Encore bien ouéj!!!
Ciao
|
| Photo By: Frank Desfours
(K:257)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
10/17/2006 9:10:41 PM
Oh Frank,
cette silhouette est superbe!!! Vraiment très suggestive, juste je couperais un peu le bas de l'image qui n'a pas trop d'interet (juste une bande) pour renforcer la composition!!!
Tous mes compliments, je voudrais bien la voir tirée...
Salut mec!!!
|
| Photo By: Frank Desfours
(K:257)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
10/9/2006 2:27:46 PM
Cia Enrico,
vedrai stampare è semplicemente fantastico. Vedere nascere l'immagine, magari di una foto che aspetti con ansia, è una sensazion carica di pathos!!! Io ho cominciato comprandomi un ingranditore e stampando nel bagno di casa mia, con mio padre che smadonnava perchè voleva pisciare nel bel mezzo di una stampa...adesso sono iscritto ad un club dove posso sviluppare e stampare in tutta comodità.
E' chiaro che la mia considerazione era un complimento!!!
Saluti
Andrea
|
| Photo By: Andrea Musi
(K:1622)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
10/9/2006 1:55:40 PM
Grazie per il commento Enrico,
in quanto alla dominante azzurra non so che risponderti. Magari è dovuta allo scanner che utilizzo che è veramente scadente...forse dovrei far scannerizzare le diapositive dal laboratorio che le sviluppa, ma il prezzo purtroppo è proibitivo.
Un saluto...m'è piaciuto l'impegno politico nelle tue foto!!! Mi piace anche che utilizzi materiale analogico, anche a costo di sembrare anacronista non riesco a farmi all'idea di scattare in digitale. Il fascino delle vecchie macchine fotografiche è semplicemente irresistibile...
Ciao compagno!!!
|
| Photo By: Andrea Musi
(K:1622)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
10/9/2006 1:11:10 PM
Hola wey!!!
Just incredible shot!!! How did you manage to don't damage you camera?
It deserves a 6...
Regards
|
| Photo By: Don Nguyen
(K:323)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
10/6/2006 4:00:47 PM
Ottima idea,
originale, dalla miniatura non immaginavo si trattasse di gondole...
Saluti
|
| Photo By: marco ds
(K:6335)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
10/6/2006 3:55:17 PM
Hola Frederico,
good capture, for me I would try to capture the moment were there is only one (or three) persons on the platform...but, as you wrote, the rush hour!!!
Regards
|
| Photo By: Frederico Alves
(K:3)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
7/18/2006 10:58:32 AM
Vraiment super, j'ai aimé toutes les photos que tu présentes dans le lien...quant à cette photo très bon choix de ligne de métro. Etant parisien d'adoption, je connais l'arrêt...t'as pu profiter d'un lumière naturelle tout en donnant l'illusion d'être dans un tunnel souterrain, excellent!!!
Salut
|
| Photo By: Sébastien Pepinster
(K:424)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
5/23/2006 10:39:44 AM
Thak you everybody for your kind comments...
Grazie a tutti per i vostri commenti, è incoraggiante per andare avanti, cercando sempre di realizzare la foto ideale!!! Un saluto da Parigi!!!
Best regards to all the usefilm users!!!
|
| Photo By: Andrea Musi
(K:1622)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
5/18/2006 9:13:45 PM
Hi Eva,
thank you for your comment. I've been looking at your photos and this is the one that more attracted my eye...look I can give you some little advices. There is one big big composition rule that you must know if you want to take good pictures, it's calles "the thirds rule" and you can find it on Google very easily...when you will know it, you'll see it's a particularly easy rule, you just have to apply it like an obsession and you will see that good results will come very quickly.
About your equipment I cannot tell you anything, because I don't use digital...I only use it when I have to scaner my films. But I really think that an old manual camera is the best to learn the basis of photography, because you cannot just press...Good luck and, a last advice, don't forget to look at the pictures of the great masters of photography, this is also very important...this way you will create an images' library in your mind 
Good luck!!!
|
| Photo By: Ieva Miltina
(K:125)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
4/13/2006 2:15:26 PM
Bardzo bardzo pieke zdjecie, naprawde!!!
Ma duzo tresci, i jest poetjckie...
Pozdrowienie!!!
|
| Photo By: Sebastian Jelinski
(K:179)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
4/13/2006 1:17:30 PM
Intense coulours, but there is something I cannot say, that makes them seem like fake and unnatural...
Regards
|
| Photo By: Elahe S. Ahmadian
(K:8695)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
4/13/2006 1:15:42 PM
Very beautiful and original, nice idea!!!
|
| Photo By: Bosnia Photo
(K:3088)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
4/13/2006 1:13:38 PM
Bella luce, peccato che non ti sei avvicinato un po' di piu'...
Saluti
|
| Photo By: Nicola Barbieri
(K:18000)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
3/22/2006 10:05:50 AM
Czesc Lukasc,
bardzo dobrze!! I like this parallelism...and the grain you obtained is good!!!
Do widzenia!!!
|
| Photo By: Lukasz Rzepinski (Łukasz Rzepiński)
(K:1211)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
3/22/2006 9:49:48 AM
Nice photo, but there is something unreal, fake on the colours that doesn't conveince me.
Regards
|
| Photo By: Bogdan Lutostanski
(K:59)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
3/22/2006 9:47:13 AM
Hola Roberto,
lo siento no quiero ser demasiado duro pero esta imagen es bastante banal. No sé Alicia como hace, pero no veo ningun color excepcional. El cielo es gris y la luz no tiene ninguna gracia.
Te explico mi punto de vista, en esta imagen no pasa nada de especial y no requiere conocimientos tecnicos particulares, bueno...es una foto que qualquier fotografo podria haber sacado. Entonces, si quieres hacer una imagen fuerte, original tienes que buscar una luz especial (amanecer,anochecer) o que pase algo interesante en el tu primer plan, o sea los turistas.
Bueno, querias criticas...espero que estas seran costructivas.
Suerte!!!
|
Photo By: Roberto Baez Duarte
(K:5317)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
3/8/2006 3:21:51 PM
Cavoli, mi sembra di vedere mia nonna...stessa stazza, stesse rughe e sempre col grembiule davanti...grande pablo!!! Veramente una bella foto, evoca tanti ricordi vissuti, di vacanze in campagna dai miei...
Un saluto
|
| Photo By: Pablo Dylan
(K:63918)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
3/8/2006 3:02:45 PM
Very beautiful capture,
the ending of the day light give a warm impression which is in harmony with the moment.
The composition and the focus are also very good.
Regards
|
| Photo By: Gurmeet Sapal
(K:691)
|
|
|
Critique By:
Andrea Musi (K:1622)
1/20/2006 4:09:50 PM
Great graphism Umran and like the other said the composition is very well done, good harmony between the elements.
Regards
|
| Photo By: Umran Dusunsel
(K:1329)
|
|
