Martha Stewart après 5 mois dans une prison d'état, et Giuliana Sgrena après 1 mois en Irak. Both were released, one was applauded while the other was shot, both by Americans. Both did their job! photos: reuters et nouvelobs
Ohhh, I see now. I am familiar with the woman's story on the right, but was confused because I hadn't heard of recent criminal released from jail that was shot by an American. The way these two photos are placed makes it appear as if you are trying to compare the two scenarios and that the woman on the right had committed a crime (which I don't believe she did, she was held hostage). I now see where you are trying to go with this, if Martha Stewart had been some hardened criminal it might have more of an impact, but she's not. She's just a homemaker type person in a high profile scandal (not someone people see as evil). I am still curious if this is your work? Your photographs? These are high profile people and must have been an awesome opportunity to photograph - would love to hear the story behind it.
Did you take both of these photos? Or is this someone else's work that you've scanned? If this is yours, are you a journalist for a newspaper? I've of course heard of Martha Stewart (she's a little cookie baker, home decorator type person who was just sentenced to jail for a short time for some "light" crime related to money.) I don't know anything of the other person, she's American too?
Oh! je ne voulais pas les comparer, mais plutôt mettre les deux faits en opposition; un qui soulève de la compassion parce que c'est un drame, la privation d'une liberté et l'autre qui... est une démonstration de ce que peut faire la popularité, l'argent, le pouvoir et la mediatisation pour ?effacer? ou retourner en sa faveur un acte qui n'attire aucune compassion. Un anonyme aurait fait la même chose et il aurait tout perdu, et sa chemise. Une est applaudie et l'autre pas, c'est un beau titre, mais excusez ce blabla. Merci, drilan
Vous avez tout à fait raison; mais malgré tout c'est possible que ce soit un accident, dans ces cas là on dit bavure... admettons! quoique ça n'excuse rien. Personnellement c'est le cas de l'autre qui me scandalise, et là on ne parle pas de pipe et de cigare,(ce qui est dérisoire) mais d'une criminelle. Pas dangereuse? C'est le seul peuple , à mon avis, capable de faire pareilles pirouettes sur un ?je regrette?. Où il y a de l'homme, il y a de l'hommerie. Merci! drilan
0 
{K:23722} 3/7/2005