|
Louise Vessey
{K:13862} 1/17/2005
|
Wow, totally amazing shot!!! A case of being in the right place at the right time!
|
|
|
Regina Rianelli
{K:24147} 7/22/2004
|
gorgeous photograph, Robert now within my Fav's List 7 +, Regina
|
|
|
Rui Pedro
{K:657} 1/11/2004
|
Beautiful light. Maybe the tree is a bit dark.
|
|
|
Girish Chonkar
{K:6903} 1/9/2004
|
Great Shot! superb colors and use of natural lighting. Suggestions from Kevin Greggain is preferable for good composition. You'll defenitely catch great shot than this.
|
|
|
Akira Yamaguchi
{K:1163} 12/1/2003
|
Really dramatic lighting! Beautiful
|
|
|
Jani Salvataggio
{K:27283} 11/17/2003
|
woooooow! this is wondeful!!!!
|
|
|
Andrius Maciunas
{K:2047} 11/12/2003
|
Excellent! Lighting make this photo very impresional. Great job...
|
|
|
Muzaffer KURTOGLU
{K:4149} 11/7/2003
|
Good light condition. Excelent perspective. Regards.
|
|
|
John Hatziemmanouil
{K:40580} 10/26/2003
|
A piece of perfection! Robert, my congratulations! This photo is surely from a PRO photographer!
|
|
|
Andrew Chambers
{K:1271} 10/26/2003
|
Excellent
|
|
|
Robert Whiteman
{K:2201} 10/19/2003
|
On dodging the grass on the left; it was lighter but with all that dark area from the trees it attracted too much attention for my taste being all by itself so it's been darkened for this version. Also for those interested the tree on the left is actually 3 trees lined up along the path.(see attached photo from my previous comment which was taken a year ago from the other side of the path) Also, this is just minutes before sunset and as I mentioned earlier, we had one more place to get to before sundown. Have you ever driven in S.F. on a Sunday afternoon during "Fleet Week"??? The traffic was something else!
Thanks again for all the comments & suggestions everyone.
|
|
|
Quantummeter .
{K:2870} 10/18/2003
|
Excellent lightning. You can breath morning air. Beautiful job. Best regards, Pablo.
|
|
|
Chris Rodriguez
{K:495} 10/17/2003
|
wow! the color and image is incredibly smooth. very inviting. nice work!
|
|
|
Mark Stein
{K:6210} 10/17/2003
|
This is a great shot! On the cropping comments...this is a tough call, on one hand the tree being so massive, makes the runner small in comparison which is a wonderful contrast. If the left side was cropped, you lose the width of the tree (you will find yourself "wondering" just how big that tree really is), which would be distracting, mentally. I might have toned the light area that is 1/3 up on the left way down but otherwise it's an excellent capture! Mark
|
|
|
Peter Ertl
{K:-8} 10/17/2003
|
good work :-)
|
|
|
Khoi Nguyen
{K:8700} 10/17/2003
|
Excellent composition. I love the sun light piercing through the tree.
|
|
|
Vlad P.
{K:1477} 10/17/2003
|
Wonderful image. This magic backlight makes it. I may agree in part with Nicole, the cars here look a little bit distracting and deserve to be cloned out. However, I wouldn't touch the other person, 'cause it's in a good agreement with the title and also add more depth. It seems that original cropping works fine, however I may agree with Roger, dodging the grass on the left would make the image better. Basically, the composition is very appealing and it's pleasant to see it among PODs. Congrats.
|
|
|
Roberto Arcari Farinetti
{K:209486} 10/16/2003
|
excellent and fantastic composition!!! magnific effects.. regrads roberto
|
|
|
Marcio Santos
{K:1451} 10/16/2003
|
The photo of the day. Excellent my friend!.....!
|
|
|
karen barnett
{K:4237} 10/16/2003
|
I have already commented and given this photo excellent marks.... BUt I am pleased to see that it is up for the critique. Is excellent that such a photo will have additional exposure. EEEK! no pun intended... but I am willig to accept credit for it! Whatever. I am still admiring this capture.
|
|
|
David Conti
{K:360} 10/16/2003
|
Magnificent photo. Very very good! I like that.
|
|
|
Adelino Barreto
{K:12661} 10/16/2003
|
Wonderfull,Rbert!Regards.
|
|
|
Felipe Rodríguez
{K:9200} 10/16/2003
|
This is the picture everyone here would like to take someday...
|
|
|
Eric Feinstein
{K:77} 10/16/2003
|
Awesome lighting
|
|
|
Rich Samuels
{K:317} 10/16/2003
|
Excellent use of lighting and composition. Would have been perfect without the two cars and rollerblader in the background.
|
|
|
ken krishnan
{K:19102} 10/16/2003
|
Wonderful capture. Great image. well done.
|
|
|
Rohan Riley
{K:308} 10/16/2003
|
Wow nice light. However i agee the composition could be improved.
|
|
|
Rick Ferreira
{K:1453} 10/16/2003
|
Fantastic photograph and the lighting is spot on. I also like Kevin Greggain's crop. Nicely done Robert!
|
|
|
Amancio Couto
{K:15720} 10/16/2003
|
add to my favorites...
|
|
|
Amancio Couto
{K:15720} 10/16/2003
|
SUPERB SHOT!...Splendid image! Congrats Robert!...Hug
|
|
|
Shiv Kumar Surya
{K:17362} 10/16/2003
|
Excellent shot. Great capture of great moment. Nice diolouge betwwen you and Kevin Greggain. Regards, 'Surya'
|
|
|
Ron ter Burg
{K:40} 10/16/2003
|
Great shot. I like the rays of light which are chasing the runner. Great job. Regards Ron.
|
|
|
Irenka Daniluk
{K:8011} 10/16/2003
|
Beautiful light... And an amazing tree! What a contrast between the powerful nature, and a week human... though a strong copy, a runner! lol
|
|
|
Tomo Radovanovic
{K:12788} 10/16/2003
|
great shot best regards
|
|
|
Roger Williams
{K:86139} 10/16/2003
|
This must be one of the finest in your entire gallery. I agree with your instinct to have rays coming from both sides of the tree, but I would have gone in there on the left with a "dodge" tool and brought that small triangle of grass up a little so that is would be more obviously linked with the backlit grass on the right. I was fascinated to hear that with all your preparation and forethought, the critical moment came and went in a flash, and you caught it just right. That's a wonderful combination, just the right balance of perspiration and inspiration.
|
|
|
david malcolmson
{K:4145} 10/16/2003
|
Wonerful light here, Robert. I like the outline of sunshine on the runner's body.Very good capture.
|
|
|
Jerry Lantz
{K:56} 10/16/2003
|
What more could I say here that hasnt been said, Great photograph Robert!
|
|
|
Donald Hanson
{K:460} 10/16/2003
|
I love this photo.........lots. What time of day was this taken? 5:00 PM? Excellent, Excellent....If you knew the runner it would be a super Photo for the wall at the house...
|
|
|
Marcos Silva
{K:709} 10/16/2003
|
Luz maravilhosa! Bela composição!
|
|
|
Ordilei Caldeira
{K:2545} 10/16/2003
|
Very good Robert! Nice composed and extreme colors in the grass. Congrats. Ordilei
|
|
|
Nicole Marcisz
{K:10268} 10/16/2003
|
I like the dramatic lighting in this image. If it were me I think the shot would be stronger if you clone out the other person and cars in background. So that the focus is on the lone runner, the dramatic light, and the negative shape of the tree.
cheers, nicole
|
|
|
A Brito
{K:10699} 10/16/2003
|
Wonderful. Make's me want to have a run after work !
|
|
|
JL E
{K:9693} 10/16/2003
|
Simply excellent! cheers, Jose
|
|
|
Nick Dechnicz
{K:36} 10/16/2003
|
Nice Lighting, good effect
|
|
|
ventrix drogo
{K:65398} 10/16/2003
|
Una luce magnifica, buona la composizione. Ottima cattura. Complimenti. Ciao
|
|
|
B:)liana
{K:30945} 10/16/2003
|
Beautiful and magical light.
|
|
|
Krystian Wystub
{K:1342} 10/16/2003
|
Excellent light! What a pity that there are these cars ...
|
|
|
Alfredo Castanheira
{K:417} 10/16/2003
|
A great great great shot!!
|
|
|
Legolas .
{K:3947} 10/16/2003
|
very good work, bye
|
|
|
Joksa Juoperi
{K:13473} 10/16/2003
|
Splendid capture with great lighting and colours. I agree with crop on the left side. Regards, Joksa.
|
|
|
Priyadarshi Sinha
{K:7238} 10/15/2003
|
lovely capture, i like the composition.
|
|
|
Debra Griffin-Ibrahim
{K:7119} 10/15/2003
|
Beautiful!!
|
|
|
karen barnett
{K:4237} 10/15/2003
|
Drama in everyday events..... created by the "magic hour" of light in the early morning... and a talented eye that realized it was magic indeed, and captured it for all to enjoy. Ambient light in all it's faceted glory is one of the most elusive components of film. You not only captured it caressing the trees, but illuminating the runner as well. This photograph is wonderful.... and a pleasure.
|
|
|
Aliyar Taravati
{K:2822} 10/15/2003
|
Wonderful light. Very good composition but I agree with the cropping suggested by Kevin Greggain.
Regards, Aliyar.
|
|
|
Robert Whiteman
{K:2201} 10/15/2003
|
Kevin, I too was taught to "look around" the subject before firing the shutter. As you could see from this photo, looking wasn't an option at the moment. I was just setting up and beginning to compose the shot with the tree when the runner appeared out of nowhere and I reacted. Lucky I had focused first and had taken a couple of shots to establish exposure levels so I was ready at the moment. There were no other runners before the light was gone and we had one more location to get to before sunset with just minutes to go. Aaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrgh.........if only the sun could be stopped for an hour or so!!! But not to be so we just keep trying.
Thanks for the comments and cropping suggestions. I personally like the "rays" comming from both sides of the tree.
I had planned to be here at this exact time having been there before a year ago to get this one. (see attachment) That was last november so the sun is still too far north (taken this past sunday). If only I could get back next month but looks like we'll be in Hawaii instead. Oh well...
Thanks to all for the comments.
|
![](http://thumbs.imageopolis.com/CritiqueImages/0/0/12-TN.jpg)
|
|
|
Elaine Collins
{K:1575} 10/15/2003
|
Very magical moment, the light was perfect. I do with the suggested crop. But, great shot either way.
|
|
|
Don Loseke
{K:32503} 10/15/2003
|
Excellent lighting. Great composition. Very well done. Don.
|
|
|
sandy c. hopkins
{K:17107} 10/15/2003
|
that light is wonderous.. nice shot.. :) sandy
|
|
|
André Bermak
{K:14443} 10/15/2003
|
Excelente captura,luz e composição.Ótimo momento!!!!!
|
|
|
Yohanes Eko Riyanto
{K:85} 10/15/2003
|
excellent rays of sun!!...nice shot!!
|
|
|
MEmar ME
{K:12566} 10/15/2003
|
Hi Robert: What a lovely composition!... Everything is perfect. A smile.
|
|
|
Dennis Fishit
{K:-251} 10/15/2003
|
excellent ..
|
|
|
Marcos Duarte
{K:15402} 10/15/2003
|
Nice shot , nice effects Abraços
marcos
|
|
|
John Chiu
{K:6250} 10/15/2003
|
Nice capture, wonderful lighting.
|
|
|
Kevin Greggain
{K:2572} 10/15/2003
|
What's up with usefilm that I can't upload images ? .. Gee..
|
![](http://thumbs.imageopolis.com/CritiqueImages/0/0/8-TN.jpg)
|
|
|
Kevin Greggain
{K:2572} 10/15/2003
|
grr.. try that one again
|
![](http://thumbs.imageopolis.com/CritiqueImages/0/0/7-TN.jpg)
|
|
|
Kevin Greggain
{K:2572} 10/15/2003
|
This is a great photo. The lighting is what makes it so great. This is a bit of extra space on the left and such so I cropped the pic down to give you an alternate view of the photo. I just had a slide entered in a competition and one of the comments they gave me was to look around the viewfinder.
Excellent photo. Great eye ..
|
![](http://thumbs.imageopolis.com/CritiqueImages/0/0/6-TN.jpg)
|
|
|
Javed Rassi
{K:8223} 10/15/2003
|
Good capture of light, composition can be improved.
|
|
|
Anna Pagnacco
{K:7448} 10/15/2003
|
Magnificent!...Anna
|
|
|
ppdix
{K:17069} 10/15/2003
|
WOW!
|
|
|
Ana Vianna
{K:15270} 10/15/2003
|
Excellent! Very beautiful work!
|
|
|
nothing nothing
{K:557} 10/15/2003
|
Pretty lighting.. not the most interesting runner though... cool shot nonetheless
|
|
|
Alex Uchôa
{K:18547} 10/15/2003
|
What a fantastic mood and timming. Perfect!!!!
|
|
|
Bob Smith
{K:2340} 10/15/2003
|
Excellent lighting. Good compostion.
|
|
|
Laurie J. Herndon
{K:5338} 10/15/2003
|
Don't you just love the "magic hours". Excellent timing. These shots don't "just" happen. It takes a very creative eye and good composition to come up with a shot like this. Nice Work. Belladonnaphoto1
|
|
|
Haleh B
{K:3741} 10/15/2003
|
Just wonderful! The rays of light are clearing the path for the runner as well as any viwer.
|
|