Kathryn: I think one problem my eyes had with this photo is the background. It seems a little dark for the dark puppy. He doesn't seem to show up as well as I think he could. I like the way he is set in the frame, however and I think he is such a cute dog. I just think a lighter background might bring him out a little more.
So helpful when someone gives a low rating and then doesn't bother to comment, isn't it? I'll try to be more helpful. Nice dog and nice background, and I like the composition, too. The reflection from the eye is a bit of a problem, though, and the focus looks rather soft (and maybe over-sharpened after).